MIGNE.APP

Cruces

De dignitate sacerdotii

Peter Damian — read the work →

These are the edition's working notes, published as they were written. They record, work by work, where Migne's plate is defective or the reading uncertain: the printed form, what the English does with it, and why. They are not a groomed apparatus. Where a note argues with itself, withdraws an earlier decision, or leaves a question open, that is the record of how the reading was actually reached, and it is left standing — a conjecture that is visible can be checked, and one that has been tidied away cannot.

The English never silently repairs the page. A construable but wrong reading is rendered literally and the conjecture is recorded here, never applied to the text. How the English is produced and checked →

Garbled or doubtful type in Migne's plate, rendered literally and logged here.

Not cruces — flagged for a human

These are Migne's citation numerals, passed through verbatim untranslated per the marker rule. None were corrected in the text.

<!-- corpus-polarity-sweep 2026-07-28 --> ## Corpus polarity sweep — 2026-07-28

Blind Opus read of the Latin/English pair for sense-reversing defects (one word or one letter asserting the opposite of what the context requires). 1 site(s). Migne's defects are recorded here and rendered literally in the English; our own errors were fixed in place. Full context: data/sweeps/corpus-polarity/REPORT.md.

0493D — sense-reversing-letter (ours, medium confidence)

Printed: Quoniam adhuc modicum, [0493D] et visitabo sanguinem Jezrahel super domum Jehu, et requiescere faciam regnum domum Israel, et in illa die conteram arcum Israel, in valle Jezrahel

Conjecture: Hosea 1:4 reads 'et quiescere faciam regnum domus Israel' — 'I will cause the kingdom of the house of Israel to CEASE' (Douay). Migne's plate prints 'requiescere' (extra re-, plus 'domum' for 'domus'), and the English has followed the printed form lexically as 'make ... to rest', turning a sentence of destruction into a promise of repose. Render 'and I will bring the kingdom of the house of Israel to an end'.

Damian cites this verse for one purpose only, stated in the sentence immediately before it: 'Quod utique nomen, quamvis prosperum significare videatur ... hic tamen vindictam Dei et furorem sonat' — 'although it seems to signify something prosperous ... here nevertheless it sounds the vengeance of God and fury.' A clause promising Israel's kingdom rest is the opposite of vindicta and furor, and it also contradicts the clauses flanking it inside the same quotation ('I will visit the blood of Jezrahel upon the house of Jehu', 'I will break the bow of Israel'). The paragraph after it repeats the point: 'Quod autem hic per Jezrahel, non salus, sive prosperitas, sed Dei potius ira signatur.'

### 0493D — sense-reversing letter (Migne's plate; resolved 2026-07-29) Printed: et requiescere faciam regnum domum Israel (Hosea 1:4).

Conjecture: quiescere faciam regnum domus Israel — "I will cause the kingdom of the house of Israel to cease" (Vulg./Douay).

Damian adduces the verse to prove that Jezrahel here sounds vindictam Dei et furorem, introducing it with cum protinus subinfertur. As printed, the oracle promises rest, so the proof-text contradicts the reading it is cited for.

Ruling (Wilson, 2026-07-29): render literally, mark inline. The scripture policy is locked — translate what Migne prints, never substitute a conventional version — so "to rest" stands, and the page now carries [sic: requiescere] so the reader meets the defect there rather than only here.

Resolved 2026-07-29 — [var: …] (Pattern 14) was added for exactly this. The page now reads "to rest [sic: requiescere] [var: Vulg. quiescere, "cause to cease"]" — Migne rendered faithfully, the received reading noted beside it. The two markers answer different questions and both are needed here: [sic:] says the type is the plate's, [var:] says the quotation disagrees with the Vulgate.

The gap that forced the new pattern is worth keeping on record: [sic: …] may only wrap type carried verbatim from the plate, so the gloss could not go inside it (the verifier rejected the attempt, correctly), and [ed: …] is reserved for text our source has lost. Scripture divergence was neither, and had nowhere to live but this file — which no reader opens.